Why are schools in Masafer Yatta at risk of demolition?
As the new school year begins, Palestinian children in Masafer Yatta, a cluster of villages in the southern West Bank, are attending classes under the constant threat that their schools could be demolished by Israeli authorities. The area, designated by Israel as a firing zone, has seen repeated attempts to remove structures deemed illegal under military law, including educational facilities. Despite international concern, the risk of demolition remains high as the academic term starts.
Breaking news
Deadly Glacier and Rock Collapse in Nepal Linked to Climate Warming
US Congress Passes Sweeping Sanctions Against Russia
Speaker Johnson Ends House Session Early to Halt Impeachment Effort
The High-Stakes Fight for Senate Majority ControlThe schools in Masafer Yatta serve over 200 children from herding and farming families who have lived in the area for generations. Many of these schools are built from temporary materials like tin and wood, making them vulnerable to demolition orders. Israeli authorities say the structures lack permits, but residents argue they are denied the ability to build legally due to restrictive zoning policies. Human rights groups have warned that demolishing schools disrupts education and violates children’s rights under international law.
How do families and educators respond to the ongoing uncertainty?
The threat stems from Israel’s declaration of much of Masafer Yatta as a closed military zone for training exercises, a designation first made in the 1980s. Since then, Israeli authorities have issued demolition orders against dozens of structures, including homes, animal pens, and schools, claiming they were built without permits in a restricted area. Palestinians in the region say they are unable to obtain permits through the Civil Administration, which governs planning in Area C of the West Bank, where Israel retains full control. As a result, any construction is considered illegal and subject to removal. The schools, though essential for local children, fall under the same regulatory framework, leaving them exposed to potential demolition at any time.
Teachers and parents in Masafer Yatta have adapted to the precarious situation by maintaining low-profile school operations and preparing emergency lesson plans. Some classes are held in tents or private homes when schools are threatened with demolition. Despite the stress, community leaders emphasize the importance of continuity in education as an act of resilience. „We teach our children not only math and Arabic, but also how to stay on their land,” said one teacher from the village of Jinba. International observers and UN agencies have repeatedly called for the protection of educational facilities, but enforcement remains limited. Families say they will continue to send their children to school as long as the buildings stand, viewing education as both a right and a form of resistance.
Why does Israel consider the schools in Masafer Yatta illegal? Israel states that the schools were built without permits in a designated firing zone where construction is prohibited under military law. The Civil Administration, which handles planning in Area C, has not granted building permits to Palestinians in the area for years, citing security and zoning restrictions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if a school is demolished? If a school is demolished, students may be forced to study in temporary shelters, private homes, or travel long distances to nearby towns, disrupting their education. Aid groups sometimes provide temporary learning spaces, but these are not long-term solutions.
Are there any legal protections for schools under international law? International humanitarian law protects schools as civilian objects and prohibits attacks on educational facilities unless they are being used for military purposes. Human rights organizations argue that demolishing schools in Masafer Yatta violates these protections, especially when they serve no military function.
